辩诉交易在目前中国的收益与成本分析

• 作 者: 郝赪 蔡志荣
• 机 构: 中央司法警官学院,保定学院,
• 出 处: 河南司法警官职业学院学报
• 发表日期: 2009年01期
• 关键词: 辩诉交易 寻租 社会资本 公信力 transaction in criminal action seeking rent social capital p

对比辩诉交易成本与收益可以分析出其整体效益。辩诉交易具有一定的内在价值,比如,能在多个环节节省时间;可节约司法资源;能有效地减少积案;对被告人、被害人及其家属、司法机关等有一定好处。然而,辩诉交易也会产生巨大成本,造成正义缺失、权力寻租,威胁司法公信力和司法价值观等一系列问题。就其整体效益而言,时间效益和经济效益之得难以弥补社会效益之失。

Compare the cost and benefits of plea bargaining can analyze its overall effectiveness. Plea bargaining has some intrinsic value, for example, it can save time in many aspects; can save judicial resources; can effectively reduce the cumulative case; to the accused, the victims and their families, the judiciary and so on have some benefits. However, plea bargaining can also generate huge costs, resulting in a series of problems such as lack of justice, rent seeking power, threats to judicial credibility and judicial values. As far as its overall effectiveness is concerned, it is hard to make up for the loss of social benefits with the benefits of time and economic benefits.