论文部分内容阅读
在中法战争110周年之际,黄振南先生编著的《中法战争史热点问题聚焦》出版了!洋洋30万字,搜罗了中外有关中法战争史论著共千余种目录,并且将史学界在中法战争史研究的分歧分门别类,详细介绍,使读者能全面了解中法战争的过去和现状,从而把握其发展趋势,堪称中法战争史研究的必备之书。这是中法战争史研究的又一可喜收获。 中法战争是清末发生的一次重要的反侵略战争。与清末其他的对外战争相比较,这是清政府唯一一次没有惨败而胜负未明的反侵略战争。而其结局,无论是交战的双方还是后来的有关当事国家的史学家们都站在不同的立场上论得论失,聚讼不休。中法战争早在一个世纪以前已经结束,但这场结局令双方都不满意的战争至今还在历史学家们中间争论,这就是中法战争史研究的魅力所在。《聚焦》全面地展现了这场旷日持久的史学界的争论,将其论争的各个侧面如战争全局、战争决策、中国方面的有关人事评价等等,按照其论点的对立程度与性质客观介绍。读者不仅可以从中了解在这一领域学术争论的深度和广度,而且可以明瞭中法战争史研究的历史及其演变。从这个意义上说,《聚焦》不失为一部颇有特色的专题史学史著作。
At the 110th anniversary of the Sino-French War, Mr. Huang Zhennan’s “Focus on the Hot Issues in the War between China and France” was published. The 300,000 words of foreign language were collected, collecting a total of over 1,000 catalogs of Chinese and foreign treatises on the history of Sino-French war, The disagreements on the research on the law history of war are divided into different categories and introduced in detail so that the readers can fully understand the past and current status of the Sino-French war, so as to grasp its development trend and be a necessary book for the study of Sino-French war history. This is another welcome harvest in the study of Sino-French war history. The Sino-French War was an important anti-aggression war in the late Qing Dynasty. Compared with other foreign wars in the late Qing Dynasty, this was the only anti-aggression war that the Qing government did not fate defeat but won. And its outcome, both warring parties and later historians of the countries concerned, stood on different points of view and lost their arguments. The war between China and France was over a century ago. However, the war that has ended the course of dissatisfaction between both sides still argues among historians so far. This is the charm of the Sino-French war history study. “Focusing” comprehensively presents the protracted debate in the historical field and objectively introduces all aspects of its controversy, such as the overall situation of war, decision-making in war, and relevant personnel evaluation in China, according to the degree and nature of its opposition. The reader can not only understand the depth and breadth of academic debates in this field, but also understand the history and evolution of the Sino-French war history research. In this sense, “focus” after all, is a rather distinctive feature historiography.