论新闻监督司法权的制约

• 作 者: 荀红
• 机 构: 人民法院报社,
• 出 处: 人民司法
• 发表日期: 2011年03期
• 关键词: 新闻监督 司法权 新闻传播学界 司法公正 媒体审判 司法过程 司法审判 刘涌案 新闻专业主义 新闻自由

新闻监督司法过程中的权力异化以2003年刘涌案为标志,新闻传播学界、法学界广泛掀起了一场长达数年的有关“媒体审判”的大争论。争论围绕新闻监督与司法公正而展开。不管争论各方的观点与依据如何,也不管争论的结果如何,一个不容置疑的事实就是,争论本身充分反映了新闻监督与司法审判之间存在冲突关系。究其原因,国内已有相当多的论述。

News Supervision The Alienation of Powers in the Judiciary Process With the case of Liu Yong in 2003 marked by signs, a major controversy over the “media trial” for many years has taken shape in the news media and law circles. The controversy revolves around news monitoring and judicial fairness. Regardless of the arguments and arguments of all parties involved in the debate and irrespective of the outcome of the controversy, it is an indisputable fact that the debate itself fully reflects the existence of a conflict between news monitoring and judicial adjudication. The reason, there have been quite a lot of discussion.