论文部分内容阅读
精神鉴定是程序正义的表现,在精神鉴定机构未作出正式鉴定之前,妄自揣摩、猜度嫌疑人是否是精神病患者而做出判决是不负责任和非理性的,也是不符合法律规定的。若李磊无精神疾病,哪怕他的行为有种种苦衷和原因,对此种丧心病狂的罪犯,法律应该严惩不贷;但若他真有精神疾病,那么即使众愤难平,即使他的行为罪大恶极,法律也应该尊重科学给予其理性、公正的评判。
Mental appraisal is a manifestation of procedural justice. It is irresponsible and irrational to arbitrate whether the suspect is a mentally ill person before trying out the formal appraisal by the psychiatric appraiser. It is also not in conformity with the law. If there is no mental illness in Li Lei, even if his behavior has various difficulties and causes, the law should severely punish and lenient the frivolous criminals. However, even if he is really mentally ill, even if he is indignant and resentful, It should also respect science to give its rational and fair judgments.