论文部分内容阅读
根据争端解决规则,争端双方都有权对专家组裁决提出上诉。但笔者认为,不管双方是否上诉,此案的裁决结果无法阻挡美国“禁烟”的脚步,烟草类产品进入美国市场会越来越难。如果美国禁止薄荷在香烟生产中的使用,并及时履行程序性的通知义务和解释义务,印尼不可能胜诉。美国会这样做的,薄荷的使用迟早会被禁止,程序性义务也很容易履行,无非是文来文往罢了。其实,印尼的烟草生产商也没有因此案的胜诉得到任何慰藉,相反,据《雅加
According to the dispute settlement rules, both parties to the dispute have the right to appeal against the panel’s decision. However, I believe that irrespective of whether the parties appealed or not, the ruling in this case can not stop the United States from stepping out of the smoking ban. It will be harder for tobacco products to enter the U.S. market. If the United States forbids the use of peppermint in cigarette production and promptly performs procedural notification and interpretation obligations, Indonesia can not win the case. If the United States would do so, the use of the mint will be banned sooner or later, procedural obligations will be easily fulfilled, and nothing will happen. In fact, Indonesia’s tobacco producers have not been any consolation of the case of victory, on the contrary, according to "Jakarta