论文部分内容阅读
《陕西金融·钱币研究》1995年1期刊登四川黄岳明先生《一块罕见的东汉记钱制的铜牍》一文(以下称黄文).称该铜牍为东汉时物,并指明“记钱制”.《陕西金融·钱币研究》8期发表陕西成增耀先生质疑文章(以下称成文),说铜牍是“记铜价”,否定“记钱制”.对于黄文,笔者认为该铜牍虽然记载了有关东汉的情况,但不是东汉时物,具体说是清代嘉庆或稍后时物.铜牍所记载的文字,最初出自(宋)王厚之辑《钟鼎款识》,该书第46页载:“后汉延光壶延光四年铜二百斤直线二千”,文字为汉隶,“铜牍”所载文字风格与“款识”所载文字风格显然不同.我国著名金石学家容庚在《钟鼎款识述评》中指出;(款识》几经碾转,嘉庆七年归于仪徵阮元,详加考释,书以隶体,以别于厚之之笔,摹刻成书.阮元定此册为王厚之所辑.该摹刻本于1985年由中华书局影印出版.清代仿古之风盛行,铜牍就是
“Shaanxi Institute of Finance and Money” 1995In January 1, Mr. Huang Yueming, Sichuan Province, published “a rare piece of bronze medallion from the Eastern Han Dynasty” (hereinafter referred to as “Huang Wen”), which he called the Eastern Han Dynasty and pointed out that “ ”Shaanxi Finance and Money Research“ issue 8 Shaanxi Cheng Zeng Yao questioned the article (hereinafter referred to as written), saying that copper is a ”copper price“, denied ”remember money system.“ For Huang, I believe that the copper 牍Although recorded about the Eastern Han Dynasty, but not the Eastern Han Dynasty, specifically the Qing Dynasty Jiaqing or later Shih Tung.The texts recorded in Tongli, originally from (Song) Wang Houzhi ”Zhongding section identification“, the book 46 The page contains: ”The Han Dynasty Yan Guang pot four years of copper 200 pounds straight line two thousand“, the text for the Han Li, ”Tong Kui“ contained in the writing style and ”paragraph identification“ contains clearly different writing style.China’s famous stone scientist Rong Geng pointed out in ”Comments on the Comments of Zhong Ding“; (paragraph of knowledge, ”After several grind turn, Jiaqing seven years at Yizheng Yizheng, detailed examination, book to the body, in addition to thick pen, This book was edited by Wang Houzhi, and was copied and published by Zhonghua Book Company in 1985. The antiquity of the Qing Dynasty flourished, Copper 牍 is