论文部分内容阅读
在对抗式诉讼模式下,不是只有公、检、法三机关才讲配合与制约,司法机关与刑事被告人之间的配合与制约同样十分重要,对该问题的忽略与漠视只会形成刑事诉讼配合与制约的失衡与紊乱。仅仅依靠人民检察院进行法律监督,无法体现法律监督的均衡性,更为科学的法律监督应当是人民检察院法律监督与人民群众法律监督相结合。以事实为根据、以法律为准绳原则体现出工具理性的局限性,在法律规定过于原则与笼统的情况下,严格执法工具理性与价值判断价值理性的集合,应该更能体现刑事裁判的科学性。
Under the adversarial mode of litigation, it is not just the coordination and restriction of the three organs of public security, prosecution and law. The coordination and restriction between the judicial organs and criminal defendants are also very important. Ignoring and ignoring this problem will only lead to the formation of criminal lawsuits Unbalance and Disorder of Cooperation and Control. The reliance on the people’s procuratorate for legal supervision can not reflect the balance of legal supervision. A more scientific legal supervision should be the combination of legal supervision by the people’s procuratorate and the legal supervision by the people. Based on the fact and the principle of law, the principle of instrumentalism embodies the limitations of instrumental rationality. When the legal provisions are too general and general, the combination of rigorously enforcing the instrumental rationality and the value rationality of value judgments should better reflect the scientific nature of the criminal judgments .