论文部分内容阅读
时下学界热议的法教义学与社科法学之争,在增进我们对于法律方法和法律思维等基本问题之认识的同时,也暴露出了它们对于彼此的一些误解和成见。在这种背景下,本文提出并捍卫了这样一个重要的理论命题:法教义学是法学的核心。这并非有意过度提升法教义学的地位,而是为了从根本上厘清法学各学科的内在脉络与基本性质。无论是从法教义学的性质、范围、功能及法学教育的理想来看,还是从社科法学在知识生产与应用上对于法教义学的依赖来分析,以上命题均是可以成立的。此外,透过新近学界所出现的“社科法学的教义化武装”和“法(教义)学的社会科学化转向”这两种现象,还应看到法教义学与社科法学相互合作与相互促进的一面。
Nowadays, the debate between legal doctrine and social science legal science, which is hotly debated by academics, has exposed our misunderstandings and stereotypes about each other while enhancing our understanding of basic issues such as legal methods and legal thinking. Against this background, this article proposes and defends such an important theoretical proposition that legal doctrine is the core of jurisprudence. This is not intended to unduly elevate the position of legal doctrines but rather to clarify the essence and essence of each discipline of law. From the perspective of the nature, scope, function and legal education ideal of legal doctrine, or from the dependence of social science jurisprudence on legal doctrine in knowledge production and application, the above propositions can all be established. In addition, through the phenomena of “the doctrine of the doctrine of the social sciences law” and “the social science of the doctrine of the doctrine”, which are emerging in the recent academic circles, we should also see that both the law doctrine and the social sciences Law mutual cooperation and mutual promotion side.