儿子伤残无力尽义务 父亲索要赡养费败诉

• 作 者: 敖颖婕
• 出 处: 老同志之友
• 发表日期: 2009年04期
• 关键词: 二审判决 成年子女 诉讼请求 登记结婚 杨子 案件经过 生活补贴 劳动能力 基本生活需要 保安工作

成年子女应当尽到赡养父母的义务,这原本是道义和法律双重的责任。然而当儿子本身因工致残,尚有幼女需要抚养,而老人又有稳定的经济收入时,老人提出的赡养要求就需要斟酌了。2008年新年前,上海市一中院二审判决了一起赡养纠纷,父亲要求残疾儿子支付赡养费的诉讼请求没有得到法院支持。

Adult children should fulfill their obligation to support their parents, which is originally a moral and legal responsibility. However, when the son itself is crippled by work and there are still young girls who need recuperation and the elderly have stable economic income, the old people’s maintenance requirements need to be weighed down. Before the 2008 New Year, the second instance of Shanghai Intermediate People’s Court ruled a dispute over the support of the court, and his father’s claim that the disabled son paid alimony has not been supported by the court.