价值理性的技术困境——关于在监控侦查中适用司法令状制度的反思

• 作 者: 杨正鸣 王慧智
• 机 构: 华东政法大学,
• 出 处: 公安学刊(浙江警察学院学报)
• 发表日期: 2008年06期
• 关键词: 监控侦查 司法令状制度 令状主义 价值理性 技术困境

监控侦查的及时性、秘密性、具象性、灵活性的要求与司法令状制度的审慎性、救济性、概括性、形式性的属性在一定程度上相抵触,这使得司法令状制度在世界各国司法实践中发挥的实效与其制度设计的初衷之间有相当的差距。因此,在关于我国是否应该在监控侦查中引入令状主义及如何引入的问题上,必须抱有冷静和审慎的态度。

The timeliness, confidentiality, figurability and flexibility of the surveillance investigation conflict with the prudence, relief, generality and formality of the judicial writ system, which makes the judicial writ system in the judicial There is a considerable gap between the actual effectiveness of practice and the original intention of system design. Therefore, there must be a calm and cautious attitude as to whether or not our country should introduce such a doctrine in the monitoring of investigations and how it should be introduced.