Learned Helplessness-A Devil that Prevents Us from Learning Well

来源 :校园英语·下旬 | 被引量 : 0次 | 上传用户:lulubukule
下载到本地 , 更方便阅读
声明 : 本文档内容版权归属内容提供方 , 如果您对本文有版权争议 , 可与客服联系进行内容授权或下架
论文部分内容阅读
  【Abstract】Nowadays, many students in this fiercely competitive society feel stressed in their academic process. A portion of them suffer from a negative psychological symptom called learned helplessness, thus they are impeded by their attitude and mind state. This article aims to learn more about learned helplessness, and illustrate its impacts on the learning process. At the last part of this article, it will discuss the ways to prevent learned helplessness in academic process.
  【Key words】learned helplessness; academic performance; attribution; negative emotion
  【作者簡介】王佳音,福建师范大学外国语学院。
  1.Background
  In this modern society, people attach more and more significance to their psychological states. With more and more people having a tight schedule, people suffer from anxiety, depression and so on. Many people may have such experience that we have made a lot of efforts, but it seems that we can never achieve the result we expect. Therefore, we hold a pessimistic attitude towards life. Such symptom may have a bad impact on our learning process.
  Learning is a complicated process which is closely connected with emotion, so it is impossible to learn something well without a good emotion control.
  Nowadays, we can find that quantities of students who suffer from some negative emotions cannot do well in their studies. Highschool learning is one of the most important stages in people’s life. However, many mental problems would arise in students’ learning process, such as learned helplessness, low self-efficiency and negative attribution in their academic achievements. Learned helplessness is the most influential one which may trap students in vicious circle of learning.
  Researches about learned helpless is quite important in learning process. In our country, the related researches are mainly theoretical ones introduced from abroad, and the researches are still not complete.
  2. Introduction of learned helplessness
  2.1 Definition of Learned Helplessness
  Learned helplessness is behavior exhibited by a subject after enduring repeated aversive stimuli beyond their control. It is characterized by the subjects’ acceptance of their powerlessness: discounting attempts to escape or avoid the aversive stimulus, even when such alternatives are unambiguously presented. Upon exhibiting such behavior, the subject is said to have acquired learned helplessness.
  2.2 Researches on Learned Helplessness   “Learned helplessness” was first proposed by American psychologist Marty Seligman. In 1967, the psychologist and his colleagues conducted an experiment on dogs. He put dogs in the cage. The cage was connected with electricity, and there is a bell in the cage. When the bell was rang, the dogs would get electric shock. They couldn’t predict the electric shocks and they weren’t able to avoid it. After several times electric shocks, the dogs didn’t try to escape from the cage even if they could, and they just moaned until the electric shocks ended.
  Later, Seligman and his colleagues conducted another experiment. The dogs were placed into a room with a short board in the middle to train their ability to avoid the electric shocking. In 10 seconds before the shocking was given, they can avoid the electric shocking.
  The experiment results showed that it was easier for dogs in the controlled group to escape from the electric shocking, while the dogs in experimental group chose to bear the shocking and didn’t do anything to react to it. After doing the experiment, Seligman named this phenomenon as “learning helplessness”.
  After the theory of “learned helplessness” was proposed, there is a popular trend in psychological field. Many psychologists had begun to study the causes and generation mechanism of learned helplessness. A lot of scholars also put forward plenty of hypothesis, which is practical in education field.
  2.3 The Theories of Learned Helplessness
  The generation mechanism is the focus of the researches on learned helplessness. There are four theories related to this phenomenon. In previous researches, some behaviorists held that learned helplessness is result from uncontrollable consequences led by environments. Attribution theory proposed that negative attribution method is the cause of learned helplessness. Cognition theory proposed that learned helplessness is caused by inconsistent information feedbacks with the solutions to the problems, and this may make people believe that their efforts are futile. The last one is achievement goal theory, this theory holds that individuals’ excessively pursuing high achievements can cause learned helplessness.
  2.3.1 The Early Hypothesis of Learned Helplessness—Non-controllability of The Behavior Result
  The early theories about learned helplessness is based on controllability. Participants know that the results cannot controlled by themselves, and this non-controllability will reduce their motivation greatly. In other word, the participants will gradually lose their motivation to make efforts because they know the result is out of control. When Seligman accounted for this phenomenon, he focused on the non-controllability and illustrated that learned helplessness is made of three connected aspects: first is the uncontrollable environment, second is adjoint cognition with which people view anything negatively, and third is self-abandon reactivity. When people come to this stage, they always hold a negative attitude towards everything and stay low self-esteemed and disappointed. Worse still, they have no desire and courage to change the current situation.   In early researches, scientists also study the relationship between the learned helplessness and depression. Researches showed that when people suffer from something out of their control, they would become anxious, helpless. As a consequence, they begin to absorb in pessimism. However, people’s controllability can resumed by making efforts.
  In addition, the researches of learned helpless add a new variable—expectance. The adjoint cognition have an impact on people’s opinion to their situation. The learned helplessness can damage people’s behavior, emotion and cognition. Nonetheless, with the development of psychology, this theory saw some limitations, and it couldn’t account for all psychological reactions under the uncontrollable situations.
  2.3.2 The Attribution Theory of Learned Helplessness
  In 1978, the psychologist Abramson and Seligman borrowed Wiener’s attribution theory, and revise the model of learned helplessness. This theory holds that the cause of learned helplessness is the wrong attribution of the bad result.
  The scientists point out that the generation of learned helplessness is not the incident itself, but people’s attribution to the negative consequences. The attribution theory of learned helplessness has three dimensions: stable and unstable, internal and external, general and specific. If people attribute their failure to unstable factors, then they suffer from helplessness temporarily. But if people attribute their failure to some stable factors, such as personal abilities, then they may suffer from helplessness for quite a long time. The internal and specific attribution makes people feel helpless to one certain incident, while the external and general attribution makes people feel helpless to all the things to be done. If people always attribute their failure to the stable, internal and general factors, they can be helpless in most of situations. So to prevent and to adjust learned helplessness needs people have a proper attribution to the results of things they have done.
  2.3.3 The cognition theory of learned helplessness
  The cognition theory of learned helplessness is proposed by Sedek and Kofta. In the process of solving problems, if the task information is inconsistent with the result, then the problem-solving process will be viewed as invalid. The repeated invalid activities may exhaust people’s cognition, accompanied with the flaws of manipulation, people would lessen their motivation to a large extent. Thus, the generation of learned helplessness is companied with negative subjective perception. Sedek and Kofta discovered that the non-controllability of subjective cognition is more influential to people than the non-controllability of behaviors.   The cognition theory of learned helplessness holds that the generation of learned helplessness is resulted from the failure to have a cognition schema of future behaviors, and this theory also proposed that the inconsistency of task information and the results is a key element of uncontrollable situation, and this element would lead to all of the symptoms of learned helpless. Chronical inconsistency of task information and the results can also cause deficiency of the emotion, such as depression, anxiety and so on.
  2.3.4 The Achievement Goal Theory of Learned Helplessness
  In 1986, the psychologist Dweck did a research and found that children with equal ability had different reaction when they were taking challenges. One group showed autonomy and the other showed a tendency of learned helplessness. When children with learned helplessness face difficulties or challenges, they tend to underestimate their abilities and showed negative attitudes towards the tasks. By contrast, children with autonomy behave more confidently than those with learned helplessness and low self-efficiency. This group of children believe that through their efforts, they can get success and solve the problems eventually.
  The two different behaviors of children demonstrated that their motivations are different. Children with learned helplessness have a psychological mode of adapting low-leveled motivation, While the children with autonomy tend to pursue a learning goal and try to make progress. When they have tasks, their goal is not avoiding failure but learning something new and succeeding. They are not so afraid of failures like those with learned helplessness, because failures can help adjust learning strategies and make a new breakthrough in their problem-solving process.
  3.The Relationship between Learned Helplessness and Academic Performance
  Many psychologists devoted themselves to the researches of learned helplessness after Seligman proposed this psychological symptom. In recent years, more and more psychologists also combined learned helplessness with academic performance. Psychologists Sutherland and Singh focus their researches on the relationship between students’ negative learning habits and their academic failure. They deduced that learned helplessness play a role as intermedia in this vicious circle. Therefore, it is necessary to learn more about how is the learned helplessness formed in the learning process.
  3.1 Causes of Learned Helplessness in Learning Process   3.1.1 Negative Evaluation of Teachers and Peers
  According to Maslow’s hierarchy of needs, everyone needs love, affection, and also wants to gain a sense of belonging. So does every student. Students need teachers’ praises and recognition as well as their peer’s positive evaluation. Learned helplessness is caused by repeated failures, and teachers and peers’ negative evaluations may be viewed as the students’ failures. As time goes by, students may think that no matter how hard they try, they would never get any positive responses. This is a external cause of learned helplessness in students’ academic performance.
  3.1.2 Inappropriate Attribution
  In 1970s, Seligman and combined Winner’s attribution theory and the theory of learned helplessness. Students’ failures in their academic performance are linked with their inappropriate attribution. When people analyze their results of their behaviors, there are six factors affecting the results—ability, degree of efforts, task difficulties, fortune, physical conditions and others’ reactions. Winner divided these six factors into three dimensions—source of attribution, stability, controllability. Among the six factors, the level of efforts is controllable, and the other five factors are uncontrollable. So if students attribute their failed results to the efforts they made, they may feel guilty and try harder next time in order to get some progress. If students attribute their failure to other external causes, they would feel frustrated towards this accident and this negative emotion would not affect their attitude to the next task. However, if students attribute their failures to some internal reasons such as their ability or their intelligence, they would feel very helpless and frustrated all the time. This negative attitude is very bad for them to deal with every task both in their study and in their life. If the students suffer from failure from time to time, they would lose confidence and stay low self-esteemed.
  3.1.3 Negative Parenting
  Zhang Wenxin (1999) considered parenting styles as a combination of parenting ideas, behaviors, children’s emotional performance and reflection. All in all, parenting also refers to the children-rearing practices and interactive behaviors which have been developed and implemented by parents.
  Both the laxity or excessive expectance of parenting are likely to cause learned helplessness. If parents pose excessive expectance to their children, they would give children too much stress. If children are always in a anxious state when they are studying, they may not get a satisfying results. When children fail in their academic performance, they would be very sensitive to the negative evaluation and lose their confidence. Likewise, if parents do not pay much attention to their children’s education, the children would feel lost in their study process. Not knowing what to do, the children’s academic performance would not make much progress and in this case, it is possible for them to suffer from learned helplessness.   3.2 The Consequences of Learned Helplessness in Academic Process
  All of the previous researches showed that learned helplessness would pose some problems and trouble in students’ academic achievements. The impact is long-standing and deserve our attention. The salient negative impacts are as follows.
  3.2.1 Low Achievement Motive
  According to the David C McClelland, the professor in Harvard University, he studied the relationship between people’s needs and motivation, and then he proposed the theory of Achievement Motive. His researches illustrated that there are three significant motives in a task situation, and achievement motive is one of them. Achievement motive can be divided into two parts, that is the motivation to achieve success and the motivation to avoid failure. Students who suffered from bad results in their exams for many times may have a much lower achievement motivation than those normal students.
  Since they don’t try to achieve a higher goal, they may not feel like making more efforts to make their academic performance better. When dealing with their study tasks, they tend to avoid difficult challenges, and thus, their capacity would not improve greatly.
  3.2.2 Low Self-efficiency
  In the1970s, the psychologist Bandura proposed the theory of self-efficiency. The self-efficiency refers to the prediction of oneself ’s ability to finish a particular task. Different people have different self-efficiency degree and the degrees of self-efficiency are different in various situations. If students have symptoms of learned helplessness, their confidence is impinged to a large degree, they may not believe they can finish their academic tasks well.
  With the suspicion of their abilities, students tend to have low achievement motivation in mind. If they stay low self-efficient for a long time, they would be struck in the sad and disappointed emotion which impair their enthusiasm in task-finishing process.
  3.2.3 Negative Emotions
  Due to the repeated failures and negative evaluation from others, the students would develop a negative thinking pattern and negative attitude. They regard themselves as a loser forever and no matter how hard they try, they will never get any improvement. When students have this thought, they tend to feel disappointed and hold a negative attitude towards everything. If students suffer from this symptom chronically, they may get a sense of anxiety, despair and so on, which is very bad for their mental health.   3.3 Methods to Prevent Learned Helplessness in Academic Process
  3.3.1 Change the Teaching approaches
  As we know, the traditional teaching methods focus on imposing knowledges to students. Some theories are too abstract for students to absorb. Students tend to get a feeling of helplessness and depression when their difficulties remain unsolved for a long time. Therefore, teachers should change their ways of teaching. To begin with, teachers can demonstrate the knowledges vividly and clearly. They can use pictures, videos or others forms of teaching tools to lower the difficulty level. When students find the knowledges is easy for them to learn, they would gain confidence and hold a positive towards their academic process.
  In addition, making the class interesting is also significant. If students find the class boring, they would lose interest and desire to learn new things. If they are forced to learn what teachers teach, the study effects will be not so good. Thus, when teachers make the class interesting, students will be ready to absorb new knowledges and have strong desire to explore what they don’t understand clearly. In this way, students’ motivation would be improved greatly, and feel less helpless.
  3.3.2 Encourage Students More
  As mentioned above, others’ evaluation has great impact on students. Positive evaluation can bring students confidence, and higher motivations. Thus, when students get any improvement, no matter how small it is, teachers and parents should praise them, and make them feel the pleasure of making progress. There are many effective ways of praising and encouraging. For example, teachers can say something to recognize students’ improvements and they can also have an eye contact with the student to show their satisfaction to the students’ behaviors. On one hand, students’ enthusiasm and motivation to study will be ignited, on the other hand, students can stay in a good mental state when they are trying to achieve academic progress.
  What’s more, students who are encouraged more can develop their self-learning capacity. When students are in a positive atmosphere of learning, they would do an overall preparation and treat their study tasks carefully. These students have lower possibilities to suffer from learned helplessness.
  3.3.3 Set Appropriate Goals
  According to the theories of achievement motivation, the strength of motivation has some relations with the difficulty level of the tasks. Therefore, students should set a goal according to their capacity. If a task is too easy or too difficult, people tend to avoid such a task, because if the task is too easy, they would not make efforts and devote their energy to the task. If the task is too difficult, people would not like to take such a trouble and just escape from it. Accordingly, students should set an appropriate goal for their academic process. If the goal is far beyond their capacity, it would be very hard to achieve their goal. When their goal is not achieved for a long time, the feeling of learned helplessness comes. However, if students can set a proper goal, they are more likely to make efforts and get improved step by step.   4. Conclusion
  As mentioned above, learned helplessness can be generated because of inappropriate attribution, wrong cognition and so on. It is important to prevent learned helplessness and its negative impacts. In the learning process, students should be encouraged more rather than be negatively evaluated. Looking deeper in the symptoms of learned helplessness in academic process enable us to help students with learned obstacles overcome the difficulties and help them make progress gradually.
  References:
  [1]Abramson. L. Y. Seligman. M. E. P.
其他文献
【摘要】为了解决以往教学过程中出现的“重学轻用”或“重用轻学”的不良倾向,本院基础商务英语课程采用了文秋芳教授提出的“产出导向法”构建了以产出为导向的教学模式,但是“始于产出,止于产出”意味着教师面临着大量频繁且需及时给出有效反馈的产出任务。为应对这一挑战,在与其他评价方式进行比较之后,基础商务英语课程在评价方式方面进行了改革,在课堂实践中采用了“师生合作评价”方式,构建了以产出为导向的基础商务英
【摘要】跨文化交流在经济发展等方面的作用越来越大,翻译是交流的重要手段,跨文化翻译工作日益繁多,各高校对学生翻译能力培养中耕注重学生跨文化素养的提高,高校教师在课堂教学中忽略了对学生跨文化翻译能力的培养,导致学生的跨文化翻译能力不足,本文基于跨文化意识培养视角对高校翻译教学设计进行了探讨,提高学生的跨文化翻译能力。  【关键词】跨文化意识;大学英语;翻译教学  【作者简介】王芳,湖北工业大学外国语
【摘要】传统意义上的中职英语教学往往会面临一个师生双方都极为尴尬的窘境,那就是學生觉得英语太难不愿去认真学,而老师的教授方法也是单纯的理论知识的灌输,这样的恶性循环下,中职生的英语学习状况不容乐观。就目前的现实情况来看中职生的后期方向都是以就业为主的,显然单纯的英语理论说教对学生是毫无益处的,因为作为学生,他们的出发点就是毕业找工作。因此,我们在英语课堂中引入了多元智能理论,通过这一理论来实现学生
【摘要】在当今信息化现代化的社会中,知识更新速度快,国际交流更加广泛,英语学习力对一个人的发展起着相当重要的作用。思维导图,一种可视化的思维工具,培养高职学生的英语学习力。  【关键词】高职;思维导图;英语学习力  【作者简介】高翃(1981-),女,江苏宿迁人,宿迁高等师范学校学前教育二系讲师,研究方向:语言学和英语教育学。  一、背景  在这样一个信息化现代化的社会,知识更新速度越来越快,知识
【摘要】本文立足于初中英语教学实践,首先对拓展性阅读的概念进行了界定,又对初中学生进行英语拓展性阅读的意义与价值进行了分析,最后又结合具体实例对初中学生英语拓展性阅读的有效教育策略进行了重点阐述与论证,旨在以拓展性阅读带给学生更好的阅读体验,推动學生初中英语阅读素养及能力更好地发展。  【关键词】初中英语;拓展性阅读;意义;教育策略  【作者简介】秦培,江苏省常州市武进区湖塘实验中学。  阅读是英
【Abstract】This article analyzed the present situation of oral English teaching in Guangxi Art School, and implemented Communicative Approach in oral English teaching in this school as an example, usin
【摘要】英语作为一门外语,这门语言交际性强,要想学好英语,不仅要了解英语文化,更要了解中国文化。在英语教学中导入中国文化既是发展和传承中国文化的重要路径,更是学生学好英语语言的关键。本文笔者就大学英语教学中中国文化的导入作了相关分析。  【关键词】大学英语;中国文化;导入  【作者简介】段晓璐(1988-),女,山西太原人,山西农业大学信息学院,讲师,研究方向:语言学。  随着国门的打开,一股英语
【摘要】小学的英语学习对学生的进一步学习英语和长远的发展有着重要的影响,小学阶段英语学习一旦拉开了距离,不仅会降低学生的英语学习兴趣,也会阻碍其它学科的同步发展。每个学生都有学习的潜能,学困生也有。因此如何激发学困生学习英语的潜能,唤醒他们的学习力,需要学校,教师和家长共同努力。本文就英语学困生的几种成因进行分析并针对性谈论和探讨激发学困生学习英语潜能的几种策略。  【关键词】小学英语;学困生;家
【摘要】中國古典文学内涵丰富,形式多样,为世人留下了许多脍炙人口的佳作。中国古典文学的翻译是让中华文化走出去的重要环节。《岳阳楼记》是北宋文学家范仲淹的经典名篇之一,其巧妙地将叙事、写景、议论、抒情相结合,句式对仗工整、节奏明快,流传至今。本文选用谢百魁译本和杨宪益夫妇的译本,在Gutt提出的关联翻译理论指导下,从语内翻译和语际翻译出发,对两个译本中叙事、写景、议论、抒情四个方面的代表性句子进行比
【摘要】教学如烹饪,教师的课要在千差万别中达到因材施教,需要做到以下几点:在课内外有善于发现美的眼睛,保护和激发学生的求知欲和好奇心;全面熟悉教材,沉下心来建造自己的教学地基;搜集教学信息,丰富教学手段;培养和坚持英语阅读,试听习惯的养成;注重课堂教学中的民主和童心;培养学生的综合素养,让学生得到知识和人格的双重升华;培养真、善、智、美的一代新人。  【关键词】自然习得;创新;童心;教育本质;外在