《茅屋为秋风所破歌》非讽谕之作——与左景仁先生商榷

• 作 者: 张浩逊
• 机 构: 常熟理工学院人文系 215500
• 出 处: 杜甫研究学刊
• 发表日期: 2006年03期
• 关键词: 杜甫草堂 《茅屋为秋风所破歌》

《文史知识》2005年第10期刊出了左景仁先生的文章《写穷苦之言以抒愤———重读〈茅屋为秋风所破歌〉》。对该文的基本论点(《茅屋》诗乃讽谕之作)及相关表述,笔者觉得有讨论的必要。首先,左文为了给自己的新说立基,认定杜甫的草堂生活“是相对安定、比较优裕的”,它沿用郭沫

“Literary and historical knowledge” 2005 the tenth issue of Mr. Zuo Jingren’s article “writing poor words to express their indignation --- re-read the hut for the autumn wind by breaking the song.” The basic argument of the article (“hut” poem is satirical) and related statements, I think there is a need for discussion. First of all, on the left, in order to establish a new foundation for his own opinion, it was found that Du Fu’s chateau life was relatively stable and relatively well-to-do.